Periodic user access reviews are a standard control over financial systems, usually quarterly for in-scope applications. The work is the same every time: extract users and roles from NetSuite, SAP and Salesforce, match them to HR records, email spreadsheets to managers, chase sign-offs, then prove removals happened. Auditors add a harder question: is the listing complete and accurate? PCAOB inspectors have flagged audit teams that did not test controls over the accuracy of user access listings (PCAOB, 2024).
Segregation of duties sits on top. The same individual able to prepare and post journal entries is one of the most frequent findings in the PCAOB’s inspection reports (PCAOB, 2025), and conflicts across systems are hard to see from inside any one of them.
Where the quarter goes
- Extracting users, roles and permissions system by system.
- Matching accounts to people, and finding leavers who still have access.
- Checking role combinations against the SOD matrix by hand.
- Integration and service accounts left out of the review.
A read-only agent does the preparation
With engini, an agent gets a toolset of read tools only: users, roles and permissions from NetSuite, SAP S/4HANA and Salesforce, and workers and managers from Workday or your HR data. It cannot change access, because it has no write tools, and engini refuses any call outside the toolset. It compares the access with HR status and with the SOD rules you define, and writes one review sheet per owner, with leavers and conflicts at the top.
Every extract runs through engini and is recorded under the person who ran it, so you can show how the listing was produced. The review itself, the sign-off and the access changes stay with your people and your normal provisioning. engini is not an identity governance product: it has no certification campaigns, no SCIM and no built-in SOD library.
NetSuite
SAP S/4HANA
Salesforce